Security questionnaire frameworks compared: SIG, CAIQ, HECVAT, VSAQ, SOC 2 and ISO 27001

Security Questionnaires

Author:

Chris Mabry

Short answer: The SIG (Shared Assessments) is the long, licensed questionnaire many financial-services and large-enterprise buyers send. The CAIQ (Cloud Security Alliance) is a free, Yes/No questionnaire for cloud providers, built on the Cloud Controls Matrix. The HECVAT (EDUCAUSE) is what colleges and universities send. VSAQ is Google's open-source template, now archived. "SOC 2" and "ISO 27001" questionnaires aren't standard documents: they're buyer-built questionnaires organized around those frameworks. Most vendors answer all of them from the same evidence: a SOC 2 report, a pen test summary and a set of policies.

On this page

  1. Which questionnaire is which? (comparison table)
  2. What's inside each one? (section maps)
  3. CAIQ vs SIG: which should we fill in?
  4. What evidence do all of them ask for?
  5. What do good answers look like? (sample answers)
  6. How does Iris handle each format?
  7. FAQ

Which questionnaire is which?

FrameworkPublisherWho usually sends itLength (as published)FormatCurrent versionCost / licence
SIG (Standardized Information Gathering)Shared AssessmentsFinancial services, insurance, large enterprises with third-party risk programsTwo pre-built scopes: SIG Lite (program-level, shorter) and SIG Core (detailed). Question counts change each edition and are set in the licensed workbook; ask the requester which edition and scope.Excel workbook, scoped by risk domainAnnual editions; the SIG page lists 21 risk domainsLicensed product; corporate license listed at $7,000/year
CAIQ (Consensus Assessments Initiative Questionnaire)Cloud Security Alliance (CSA)Buyers of cloud and SaaS servicesCAIQ v4.0: 261 questions; CAIQ v4.1: 283 questions; CAIQ-Lite (v4.1): 138 questionsExcel, Yes/No/NA plus comments, with shared-responsibility columnsCCM and CAIQ v4.1 (now combined into one file)Free download; no license needed for internal use
HECVAT (Higher Education Community Vendor Assessment Toolkit)EDUCAUSEColleges and universitiesEarlier releases: Full (250+ questions) and Lite (70+). HECVAT 4 combines them in one fileExcel workbookHECVAT 4 (released Feb 2025; point releases since)Free from EDUCAUSE
VSAQ (Vendor Security Assessment Questionnaire)Google (open source, 2016)Occasionally used as a template by buyersFour templates: web application, security and privacy program, infrastructure, physical and data centerInteractive web app (JSON templates)Repository archived Nov 25, 2022Apache 2.0
SOC 2-based questionnaireNone (buyer-built)SaaS buyers' security teamsVariesSpreadsheet or portalBuilt around the AICPA Trust Services CriteriaOften answered partly by sharing your SOC 2 report under NDA
ISO 27001-based questionnaireNone (buyer-built)Enterprises with ISO-aligned programs, often outside the USVariesSpreadsheet or portalBuilt around ISO/IEC 27001:2022 Annex A (93 controls in 4 themes)Standard is sold by ISO; questionnaires are the buyer's own

What's inside each one?

Section maps below are written in our own words to help you plan who answers what. They are not the official question text.

SIG: 21 risk domains

The Shared Assessments SIG page lists 21 risk domains. A requester scopes the SIG to the domains that matter for your relationship, so you'll rarely see all 21.

Area (our grouping)SIG risk domains in itWho on your team usually answers
Governance and riskEnterprise Risk Management; Compliance Management; Information Assurance; ESGSecurity lead, compliance, legal
People and placesHuman Resources Security; Physical and Environmental SecurityHR, facilities, security
Technology controlsAccess Control; Application Management; Endpoint Security; Network Security; Server Security; Cloud Services; IT Operations ManagementEngineering, IT, DevOps
Threats and incidentsThreat Management; Cybersecurity Incident Management; Operational ResilienceSecurity operations, SRE
Data and privacyAsset and Information Management; Privacy ManagementPrivacy, data owners
Third parties and AINth Party Management; Supply Chain Risk Management; Artificial IntelligenceProcurement, security, AI/ML owners

CAIQ: 17 Cloud Controls Matrix domains

CAIQ questions map one-to-one to CSA's Cloud Controls Matrix (CCM). The CCM is "composed of 197 control objectives that are structured in 17 domains," per CSA's CCM page.

Domain (CSA code)What it covers, in plain terms
A&AAudits and how you act on findings
AISSecure development and APIs
BCRBusiness continuity, backups, resilience
CCCChange and configuration management
CEKEncryption and key management
DCSData center and physical security
DSPData classification, privacy, retention, deletion
GRCPolicies, risk management, exceptions
HRSBackground checks, training, offboarding
IAMIdentity, access reviews, privileged access, MFA
IPYData portability and exit
IVSInfrastructure, network and virtualization security
LOGLogging, monitoring, alerting
SEFIncident response and forensics
STASupply chain and subprocessors
TVMVulnerability management and pen testing
UEMEndpoint management

Full detail: CAIQ v4 and CAIQ Lite guide.

HECVAT: higher-ed focus

HECVAT asks the same core security questions as the others, plus topics universities weight heavily: accessibility, student-data privacy, data location, single sign-on with campus identity, and (since HECVAT 4) AI and privacy questions. Full detail: HECVAT vendor guide.

SOC 2-based and ISO 27001-based questionnaires

These are organized by the buyer, not a publisher:
- SOC 2-based: grouped by the five Trust Services Criteria categories (Security, Availability, Processing Integrity, Confidentiality, Privacy). Security is always in scope; the others depend on your report. Many questions can be answered with "See SOC 2 Type II report, section X," if the buyer accepts the report under NDA. Expect a bridge letter request if your report period ended months ago.
- ISO 27001-based: grouped by the four Annex A themes in the 2022 edition: organizational, people, physical and technological controls. Answer from your own policies. Never claim certification you don't hold.

CAIQ vs SIG: which should we fill in?

Fill in the one the buyer sends. If the buyer lets you choose, or you're deciding what to publish proactively:

QuestionCAIQSIG
Who expects it?Cloud buyers broadlyFinancial services and enterprise TPRM teams
Cost to obtainFree from CSALicensed (the requester often supplies it)
Answer styleYes/No/NA plus commentsMostly Yes/No/NA plus comments, scoped by domain
Can you publish it?Yes: a completed CAIQ can be submitted to the CSA STAR Registry for STAR Level 1 (self-assessment)Check your licence terms before sharing a completed SIG publicly
Typical strategyComplete once, keep current, share proactivelyKeep a current SIG Lite ready; complete Core on request

What evidence do all of them ask for?

Keep these current in one place, with an owner and a review date for each:

  • [ ] SOC 2 Type II report (and a bridge letter if the period ended more than a few months ago)
  • [ ] Executive summary of your latest third-party penetration test
  • [ ] Information security policy and acceptable use policy
  • [ ] Access control policy (MFA, access reviews, privileged access)
  • [ ] Incident response plan and breach-notification commitments
  • [ ] Business continuity and disaster recovery plan, with test dates
  • [ ] Data retention and deletion policy
  • [ ] Encryption standard (in transit and at rest)
  • [ ] Subprocessor list
  • [ ] Vulnerability management and patching policy
  • [ ] Vendor (third-party) risk management policy
  • [ ] Privacy policy and data processing agreement (DPA)
  • [ ] AI usage policy, if your product uses AI

What do good answers look like?

Examples below are written for a fictional company, "Fernhill Software." They show patterns, not wording to copy. Replace every detail with what your own policies say.

Question type: MFA for administrative access (appears in every framework)

Answer: Yes.
Comment: Multi-factor authentication is enforced through our identity provider for all workforce access to production systems and administrative consoles. Exceptions require security-team approval and are reviewed quarterly. See Access Control Policy §4.2 (attached).

Why it works: a direct answer, scope stated, how exceptions are handled, evidence cited.

Question type: encryption at rest

Answer: Yes.
Comment: Customer data is encrypted at rest using our cloud provider's managed key service. Keys are rotated per our Encryption Standard (attached). Backups are encrypted the same way.

Why it works: no unnecessary cipher detail that will go stale; points to the policy that owns the detail.

Question type: something you don't do yet (honest partial)

Answer: No.
Comment: Fernhill does not currently hold ISO/IEC 27001 certification. Our security program is assessed annually through a SOC 2 Type II examination; the report is available under NDA.

Why it works: a straight "No" with a compensating control is better than a vague "In progress." Reviewers check.

How does Iris handle each format?

FormatWhat Iris does
SIG, CAIQ and HECVAT workbooks (XLSX, XLSM, XLS)Annotates every cell as question, answer, dropdown or section across tabs, including Yes/No plus comment columns, and writes answers back into the original workbook
Word or PDF questionnairesExtracts every question, keeps the numbering, and exports into the document or a branded template
Buyer portalsThe Chrome extension extracts radio, dropdown, checkbox and text fields and drafts answers on the page
EvidenceAttach SOC 2 reports, pen tests and policies to answers; Iris suggests that evidence again when the answer is reused

Every draft comes only from your own content, links to its sources and carries a High, Medium, Low or Contradictory label. When your policies don't cover a question, Iris answers "There is not enough information to answer the question" and leaves it for a reviewer. More: security questionnaire automation.

Iris is rated 4.8/5 on G2 from 92 reviews (November 2026). Try Iris free on an RFP you've already answered.

FAQ

What's the difference between SIG Lite and SIG Core?
SIG Lite is the shorter, program-level scope for lower-risk relationships or first screening. SIG Core is the detailed scope for higher-risk relationships. Both come from the same Shared Assessments question library, which is licensed.

Is the CAIQ free?
Yes. CSA offers the CCM and CAIQ for download, and says no license is needed for internal use. The v4.1 CAIQ-Lite is a 138-question subset (per CSA).

Is there an official SOC 2 questionnaire?
No. SOC 2 is an attestation report against the AICPA Trust Services Criteria. "SOC 2 questionnaires" are buyer-built. Sharing your report under NDA often answers most of them.

Does HECVAT still have a Lite version?
HECVAT 4 (February 2025) combined the Full, Lite and On-Premise versions into one file, per EDUCAUSE. See the HECVAT guide.

Is VSAQ still maintained?
No. Google's VSAQ repository was archived on November 25, 2022 and is read-only. Some buyers still use its templates.

Which security questionnaire software handles all of these?
See our unranked security questionnaire software guide and test any tool on your own workbook.

See it live

Respond to RFPs
without the grind.

Book a demo and see your real auto-fill rate on a translation
RFP from your pipeline.