RFP strategy: how to win more RFPs, with best practices and mistakes to avoid

RFP Tips

Author:

Chris Mabry

Short answer: A winning RFP strategy comes down to five decisions: bid on fewer, better-fit RFPs; engage the buyer before the RFP when you can; write two or three win themes with proof and carry them through every section; build answers from approved, current content instead of starting from scratch; and review the draft the way an evaluator will score it. Then ask for a debrief every time and feed what you learn back into the next bid. Most teams lose more points to weak qualification and generic answers than to price.

In Iris: go/no-go discipline in the RFP Analyzer, drafts from your approved answers with sources, and reviewer approval before answers enter your library.

Who this is for: proposal leads, sales engineers and sales leaders who want a higher win rate, not just more submissions.

What decides whether you win an RFP?

DecisionStrong practiceCommon failure
Which RFPs to answerWritten go/no-go criteria, applied every timeAnswering everything because "you have to be in it to win it"
When you engageTalk to the buyer before the RFP; influence requirements via RFIsFirst contact is the RFP itself
What you say2–3 win themes tied to the buyer's goals, each with proofGeneric company boilerplate
Where answers come fromApproved, current content, tailored at the topCopy-paste from the last response, unchecked
How you reviewEvaluator-style review against the criteriaProofreading only, the night before

How do you choose which RFPs to bid on?

Use a scorecard and a threshold. Typical criteria: fit with your product, relationship with the buyer, whether you can meet every mandatory requirement, competition and incumbent, deal value versus effort, and timing. Agree the threshold in advance so the decision isn't made under deadline pressure. Template: go/no-go scorecard.

Saying no is part of the strategy. Every low-fit bid takes SME time from a winnable one.

How do you write win themes that score?

A win theme is a benefit to the buyer, linked to a feature of your offer and backed by proof. Repeat it in the executive summary, the relevant answers and the presentation.

Before (generic):

"We are an industry-leading provider committed to excellence and customer success."

After (specific, fictional vendor):

"Your RFP names reducing ticket backlog before the spring enrolment peak as the top goal. Our phased rollout puts the self-service portal live in phase one, so student password resets move off the help desk before peak. [Comparable customer, named, with their permission] used the same approach."

Why it works: it quotes the buyer's own goal, ties a specific part of the offer to it, and points to proof. Note the proof must be real and attributable; if you don't have it, leave the claim out.

More on structure: RFP executive summary template.

How should you reuse content without sounding generic?

  • Start from approved answers with an owner and review date; don't reuse anything expired.
  • Tailor the first sentence of each important answer to the buyer's wording.
  • Keep facts consistent across the RFP, the security questionnaire and your policies; evaluators notice contradictions.
  • Add new approved answers after every bid, so the library improves with each response.

What are the most common RFP mistakes?

MistakeFix
Missing a mandatory requirementBuild a compliance matrix on day one
Ignoring format rules (page limits, file names, forms)Copy the instructions into a checklist and tick it off
Answering a different question than the one askedAnswer in the first sentence; mirror the question's wording
Features without benefitsLink each feature to the buyer's stated goal
Unsupported claims and superlativesUse attributable proof or remove the claim
Inconsistent answers across documentsOne approved source of truth
Last-minute SME requestsAssign on day two with internal deadlines
Pricing disconnected from the solutionPrice team in the kickoff, not the last day
Not asking questions during the Q&A windowSubmit questions early; they can shape addenda
Never asking for a debriefAsk after every award, win or lose

How do you review a draft like an evaluator?

Give reviewers the evaluation criteria and ask them to score the draft, not edit it. Then fix the lowest-scoring, highest-weighted sections first. See how RFPs are scored for the scoring mechanics.

10-point pre-submission check

  • [ ] Bid decision recorded and still valid
  • [ ] Every requirement mapped in the compliance matrix
  • [ ] Win themes appear in the executive summary and key answers
  • [ ] Every claim has proof or is removed
  • [ ] Answers consistent with security documents and policies
  • [ ] No expired or unapproved content
  • [ ] Format, page limits and forms match instructions
  • [ ] Pricing matches the solution and required format
  • [ ] All addenda acknowledged
  • [ ] Submitted with time to spare

How do you learn from wins and losses?

Record the same fields on every bid, ask for debriefs, and review patterns quarterly. See win/loss analysis.

How Iris supports a disciplined RFP strategy

  • Go/no-go before writing. The RFP Analyzer extracts requirements and scoring criteria with citations, checks each requirement against your content (met, partial, likely not met), and rolls your own criteria into a qualification percentage and a Go, Review or No-Go recommendation.
  • Approved answers first. Drafts come from your Approved Answers Library and Knowledge Map, keeping approved wording where it matches, with a source and confidence label on every answer.
  • Honest gaps. When your content doesn't cover a question, Iris says "There is not enough information to answer the question" instead of guessing, so reviewers know exactly what needs an SME.
  • Review flow. Assign questions to SMEs or groups, use several reviewers per question, and approve answers into the library; nothing becomes your source of truth without sign-off.
  • Content that stays current. Owners, expiration dates and review cadences on approved answers; owners of expiring files are reminded before they expire.

Customer-reported: BuildOps says it cut RFP completion time by over 60% with Iris (BuildOps case study).

Iris is rated 4.8/5 on G2 from 92 reviews (November 2026). Try Iris free on an RFP you've already answered.

FAQ

What is the best RFP strategy?
Bid selectively, engage early, write proof-backed win themes, build from approved content, and review against the evaluation criteria.

How do you increase your RFP win rate?
Usually by bidding on fewer, better-fit opportunities and making high-weight sections stronger, not by answering more RFPs.

What is the most common reason RFPs are lost?
It varies; debriefs often point to weak fit or generic answers rather than price alone. Track it in your own debriefs.

Should we always respond to RFPs from existing customers?
Usually yes, but still run the go/no-go; an incumbent bid needs its own strategy.

How early should we start on an RFP?
The day it arrives: go/no-go, shred and assign in the first two days.

See it live

Respond to RFPs
without the grind.

Book a demo and see your real auto-fill rate on a translation
RFP from your pipeline.