ChatGPT or Claude for RFPs and security questionnaires vs a dedicated tool

Security Questionnaires

Author:

Chris Mabry

Disclosure: we make Iris, a dedicated RFP and security questionnaire tool. We also use and like general AI assistants, and Iris's own drafting runs on Anthropic Claude models through Amazon Bedrock. This page is about when a general assistant is enough and when it isn't, not about which model is "smarter."

Short answer: ChatGPT, Claude, Copilot or Gemini can draft good individual answers if you paste in the right source material. They're often enough for a few questions or a short RFP. They get harder to rely on when you have a 300-row Excel questionnaire, dozens of policies that change, reviewers in three teams, and a buyer who needs answers back in their own file or portal. A dedicated tool adds governed content (which answers are approved and current), citations to your own documents, blanks instead of guesses, the buyer's file format, and review and audit. Many teams use both: they keep their assistant and connect it to governed answers.

On this page

  1. What can a general AI assistant do well for RFPs?
  2. Where do general assistants struggle?
  3. Side-by-side: general assistant vs in-house build vs dedicated tool
  4. What happened when one customer tested both?
  5. How to test both on your own RFP
  6. Using both: connect your assistant to governed answers
  7. FAQ

What can a general AI assistant do well for RFPs?

  • Rewrite and tighten an answer you already have, to a word limit or a tone.
  • Summarize a long RFP and pull out deadlines and requirements for a first read.
  • Draft a first pass of narrative sections (executive summary, company overview) from material you paste in.
  • Translate an approved answer.
  • Brainstorm win themes or questions to ask the buyer.

With enterprise licenses and connectors, assistants can also search some company content. If your volume is a handful of RFPs a year and one person owns the content, this may be all you need.

Where do general assistants struggle?

NeedWhy it's hard with a general assistant alone
Knowing which content is approved and currentAn assistant searches what it can reach. It doesn't know that the 2024 retention policy was replaced, or that Legal never approved a draft answer in someone's folder.
Citing your own source for every answerAssistants connected to company content can cite the files they drew on, but a citation shows where text came from, not whether that answer was approved or is still current.
Saying "I don't know"Assistants are built to be helpful and fluent. Unless you prompt carefully every time, a question your content can't answer can still get a plausible answer. In a security questionnaire, a confident wrong "Yes" is the costliest error.
The buyer's formatCopying 300 rows in and out of a chat breaks dropdowns, multi-column answers (Yes/No plus comments) and cell positions. Portals with radio buttons and checkboxes are worse.
Many contributorsAssigning questions to InfoSec or Legal, collecting approvals and tracking who changed what doesn't happen in a chat thread.
Getting better next timeAnswers approved in one chat don't automatically become the starting point for the next RFP.
Access controlA shared assistant prompt can surface content some users shouldn't see.

Side-by-side: general assistant vs in-house build vs dedicated tool

General assistant (ChatGPT, Claude, Copilot, Gemini)In-house build on an LLMDedicated RFP / questionnaire tool
SetupAlready licensedEngineering projectVendor onboarding
Drafts from your contentIf you paste or connect itYes, as builtYes
Knows what's approved and currentNo, by defaultOnly if you build governanceUsually (approval, owners, expiry; test it)
Per-answer citations to your sourcesVariesAs builtUsually (test it)
Leaves blanks when content is silentOnly with careful promptingAs builtVaries by tool (test it)
Excel / Word / PDF / portal round-tripManual copy-pasteMust be built and maintainedCore feature (test with your files)
Assignments, approvals, audit trailNoMust be builtYes
Who maintains itThe vendorYour team, after the builder moves onThe vendor
Best forLow volume, one owner, narrative sectionsTeams with spare engineering and unusual needsSteady volume, many contributors, security questionnaires in buyer formats

For in-house builds, ask: who maintains questionnaire parsing, export into each buyer's format, permissions and the audit trail a year from now?

What happened when one customer tested both?

Cresta, a contact-center AI company, ran its own bake-off on one 41-question RFP, comparing Iris with three other AI tools (Glean, Claude and ChatGPT), and graded the answers itself:

Result (Cresta's grading)IrisThree other AI tools
Answers usable as-is28—
Answers needing major rework012, 14 and 33
Left blank and routed to an expert instead of guessed7—

Customer-reported; one customer, one RFP. Your results will depend on your content. Run your own test (below). The point isn't that one model is smarter. Where Iris didn't find enough support in Cresta's content, it left the answer blank and routed it to an expert instead of guessing.

How to test both on your own RFP

  1. Pick an RFP or security questionnaire you've already submitted, so you know the right answers.
  2. Give the general assistant and the dedicated tool the same source documents. Include two that contradict each other, and leave out anything covering 3–5 planted questions.
  3. Have each draft every answer.
  4. Grade every answer: usable as-is, minor edit, major rework, or correctly left blank.
  5. Count wrong confident answers separately.
  6. Time the parts that aren't drafting: getting answers back into the buyer's file, routing to reviewers, finding sources. That's where the difference usually shows.

Using both: connect your assistant to governed answers

You don't have to choose. Iris's MCP connector lets Claude, ChatGPT, Microsoft Copilot or Gemini query Iris's approved answers and Knowledge Map, with each user's permissions, once an org admin turns it on. Your team keeps the assistant it likes; the answers come from governed, cited content. Ask Iris also works in Slack, Microsoft Teams and a Chrome extension.

What a dedicated tool like Iris adds:

  • Drafts only from your own content, each answer linked to its sources with a High, Medium, Low or Contradictory label.
  • "There is not enough information to answer the question" instead of a guess; those answers can't be approved as-is.
  • Excel workbooks (multi-tab, dropdowns, Yes/No plus comments), Word and PDF in, and back out into the original file.
  • Assignments, approvals, and every edit and approval logged with who and when.
  • Your data is never used to train AI models.

Iris is rated 4.8/5 on G2 from 92 reviews (November 2026). Try Iris free on an RFP you've already answered.

FAQ

Can ChatGPT write RFP responses?
It can draft good answers from material you provide. Check every factual claim against your own approved sources, and watch for confident answers to questions your content doesn't cover.

Can I use ChatGPT or Claude for security questionnaires?
For a few questions, yes, with care. For a full workbook, the risks are wrong "Yes" answers, broken spreadsheet formatting and no record of who approved what. Test on a questionnaire you've already answered.

Is it safe to paste security policies into a general AI assistant?
That depends on your license terms and company policy. Check how your plan handles data retention and training, and who in your company can see shared chats.

Is a dedicated RFP tool more accurate than ChatGPT?
Not necessarily on any single answer. The difference is in grounding, citations, saying "I don't know," format handling and review. Measure it on your own RFP.

Do dedicated RFP tools use the same AI models?
Often, yes. Iris drafts with Anthropic Claude models through Amazon Bedrock. What differs is what the model is allowed to use and what happens around it.

What about Copilot for RFPs?
The same trade-offs apply. Iris's MCP connector works with Microsoft Copilot as well as Claude, ChatGPT and Gemini.

See it live

Respond to RFPs
without the grind.

Book a demo and see your real auto-fill rate on a translation
RFP from your pipeline.